Florida woman argues her unborn baby should be released from jail

Stock photo of a pregnant woman's belly

Stock photo of a pregnant woman’s belly

Yvette Harrell was six weeks pregnant when she fatally shot another woman.

Now in prison awaiting trial, she claims her unborn baby is being unlawfully detained.

In an emergency petition in a Florida court, Ms Harrell’s lawyer argued that jail staff have endangered the child through “a lack of reasonable and necessary prenatal care”.

The argument draws on the concept that a foetus is a person with rights.

The idea that an unborn child is a person with constitutional protections has gained traction since the US Supreme Court overturned the nationwide right to an abortion, known as Roe v Wade, last summer.

Ms Harrell’s “unborn child is a person as defined under the Florida Constitution and United States Constitution”, attorney William Norris wrote in a legal submission.

The filing was made on behalf of the unborn child and calls for Harrell to be evicted from jail until the child is born so he can receive proper care.

“An unborn child has rights independent of its mother, even though it’s still in the womb,” Mr Norris told The Washington Post. “The unborn child has been deprived of due process of law in this incarceration.”

Ms Harrell has been jailed without bond in Miami-Dade County since last July, after she shot Gladys Yvette Borcela, whom she was traveling with in an Uber.

The 24-year-old has pleaded not guilty to second-degree murder.

According to Mr Norris’ petition, Ms Harrell acted in self-defence, “in fear of her life and the life of her unborn child”.

He alleges that, in prison, his client has not received the prenatal vitamins, food and liquid she needs or has taken to her scheduled doctor’s appointments, and was at one point left in a transport van without air conditioning while temperatures soared over 100F (38C) ).

Ms Harrell’s last medical examination was in October, Mr Norris added, making it unclear how far along the pregnancy is or when the baby is due to be delivered.

In a statement, the Miami-Dade County Corrections and Rehabilitation Department said it was “conducting a full review of the health services offered and received to ensure that all pre-natal care being provided in our custody is appropriate”.

On Monday, Florida Attorney General Ashley Moody’s office called for the petition to be dismissed, noting it did not include adequate evidence to support Ms Harrell’s claims of neglect.

But Michael O’Brien, the father, told NBC Miami he was concerned for the child’s wellbeing.

“I don’t want the baby to be born prematurely or low birth weight,” he said. “The conditions are terrible and I feel she’s not getting the pre-natal care she should be getting.”

Scroll to Top